I can’t read minds so I’ll assume the experiences described here are real and useful. However, it should be pointed out every time this company comes up that they are not teaching the Jhanas and neither do the teachers on which they base their methodology, the so called “lite jhanas”. They themselves admit not really caring about whether what they teach are real jhanas, but are more than happy to keep the association instead of calling it something else.
The full argument is very long but it can be summarized as “Study chapter 8 of Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakosa with a qualified teacher”.
A summary of that chapter is that the jhanas are achieved by using the natural factor of one-pointedness to focus on a wholesome object upon which an ease of body and mind arises. You progress through the rest of the series when certain mental factors drop off on their own. Specifically, the mental factors that allow you to move your focus from the original object drop off at the second jhana.
The lite jhanas instructions they use invert this sequence. You focus on the bliss sensations constantly monitoring and trying to up them through feedback loops. Which means that at best you are in the first jhana but more likely that very monitoring prevents you from reaching it, let alone moving past it. What they call the higher jhanas appear to be instead variations on the emotional content of the experience, not the dropping off of mental factors.
Of course creating a feedback loop based on a good sensation will induce states of extreme bliss, but the jhanas are about the refinement of one pointedness where the initial ease (which is not really the extreme bliss they mention) drops off eventually.
So if you want to get high feel free to go but if you want to learn jhanas consider studying the chapter mentioned above and finding a teacher whose practice aligns with it.
I have a vivid memory of one meditation I had that was unlike any other meditation I have tried. I did not have a long-term change like Ben describes, and I don't know how to describe it other than I disconnected from the world, and existed in a trance.
At the time I had tried meditation thanks to a friend who loved it, and I had discovered its value in helping me take short naps and nothing more, so in true fashion, I set an alarm. When it went off, I could hear it, but it just existed in a stream of everything else, and over 10 minutes went by of it beeping next to me before I eventually had the thought that I had set it on purpose and slowly came back to awareness.
I've not been able to replicate it, but I wish I could because it was wonderful.
This is ultimately the goal of self reflection and self knowledge: to be able to see how you are without the filter of what you were, or want to be in order to ground yourself in the world and you as it is.
If you can sit in that space truthfully and comfortably then that’s a good start. From there you get to sort out where you are supposed to be, as you define it, and what that means for the relationships with the rest of the parts of the universe.
That’s not the end but the author is describing what it feels like to be able to fully comprehend yourself. Best of luck on your journey!
I have been asked over the years to describe my meditation practice and I wrote it up here not long ago in case anyone is curious: https://kemendo.com/meditation.html
I can tell you that a) I bought a leather-bound set of the gospels, the Dhamapada, the Tao Te Jing, the Torah, the Bhagivad Gita, and b) I read Reza Aslan’s book, Jesus the Zealot.
It sure looks like an ad. Even the premise of a "SF meditation startup" sounds pretty bizarre. I wonder what the overlap with the "orgy houses" is?
I suspect people are seeing the title and assuming it's someone talking about meditating and becoming a better person. No, it's a hype piece for a specific SF meditation retreat thing.
If Buddhist practice is really difficult, and makes you perceive every single sensation as profoundly unsatisfactory in some hard-to-define way, and can plunge you into a neverending depression which you might get out of if you meditate hard enough, and then gives you a sort of permanent annoying low-grade bipolar disorder even if you succeed, then we're going to need something better than pithy quotes."
Started meditating in high school, achieved a temporary awakening where it felt like I was on mushrooms, before I tried mushrooms. Without any visuals of course. You could spit in my face I wouldn't care, I was that happy and content.
Next day.. regular old me. The contrast was so stark it plunged me into a depression because I couldn't achieve that high again.
My advice, don't get into this without a teacher who you trust and is far along that path.
Now I'm back to being Orthodox Christian so wouldn't recommend following that path at all but if you are really interested in Buddhism, at least do it with a good teacher.
> * Ironically, Jhourney more or less recommends doing this in various parts of the handbook, but I was too into following rules to follow the part of the rules where they told me to stop following the rules.
LOL
This retreat sounds awesome and I really wish I could afford one!
Edit: Oh, they disallow BorderlinePD and CPTSD, both of which I have:
> Diagnosed or symptoms of borderline personality disorder or complex-PTSD in the last 3 years
I was really excited (and have no hope that anything else comparable will ever happen), but I guess it's not for me.
IIRC, intense meditation can really change one’s experience of those conditions, sometimes for the better, but sometimes making symptoms markedly worse.
I did a 10 day Vipassana retreat a long time ago. Back then it was run by donations and the suggested amount was a couple hundred dollars. They're not out to make money.
I can’t read minds so I’ll assume the experiences described here are real and useful. However, it should be pointed out every time this company comes up that they are not teaching the Jhanas and neither do the teachers on which they base their methodology, the so called “lite jhanas”. They themselves admit not really caring about whether what they teach are real jhanas, but are more than happy to keep the association instead of calling it something else.
The full argument is very long but it can be summarized as “Study chapter 8 of Vasubandhu’s Abhidharmakosa with a qualified teacher”.
A summary of that chapter is that the jhanas are achieved by using the natural factor of one-pointedness to focus on a wholesome object upon which an ease of body and mind arises. You progress through the rest of the series when certain mental factors drop off on their own. Specifically, the mental factors that allow you to move your focus from the original object drop off at the second jhana.
The lite jhanas instructions they use invert this sequence. You focus on the bliss sensations constantly monitoring and trying to up them through feedback loops. Which means that at best you are in the first jhana but more likely that very monitoring prevents you from reaching it, let alone moving past it. What they call the higher jhanas appear to be instead variations on the emotional content of the experience, not the dropping off of mental factors.
Of course creating a feedback loop based on a good sensation will induce states of extreme bliss, but the jhanas are about the refinement of one pointedness where the initial ease (which is not really the extreme bliss they mention) drops off eventually.
So if you want to get high feel free to go but if you want to learn jhanas consider studying the chapter mentioned above and finding a teacher whose practice aligns with it.
I have a vivid memory of one meditation I had that was unlike any other meditation I have tried. I did not have a long-term change like Ben describes, and I don't know how to describe it other than I disconnected from the world, and existed in a trance.
At the time I had tried meditation thanks to a friend who loved it, and I had discovered its value in helping me take short naps and nothing more, so in true fashion, I set an alarm. When it went off, I could hear it, but it just existed in a stream of everything else, and over 10 minutes went by of it beeping next to me before I eventually had the thought that I had set it on purpose and slowly came back to awareness.
I've not been able to replicate it, but I wish I could because it was wonderful.
I'd be interested to read the handbook, is it published online anywhere?
There is a copy on scribd it seems.
This is ultimately the goal of self reflection and self knowledge: to be able to see how you are without the filter of what you were, or want to be in order to ground yourself in the world and you as it is.
If you can sit in that space truthfully and comfortably then that’s a good start. From there you get to sort out where you are supposed to be, as you define it, and what that means for the relationships with the rest of the parts of the universe.
That’s not the end but the author is describing what it feels like to be able to fully comprehend yourself. Best of luck on your journey!
I have been asked over the years to describe my meditation practice and I wrote it up here not long ago in case anyone is curious: https://kemendo.com/meditation.html
I can tell you that a) I bought a leather-bound set of the gospels, the Dhamapada, the Tao Te Jing, the Torah, the Bhagivad Gita, and b) I read Reza Aslan’s book, Jesus the Zealot.
I struggle to be dispassionate on these subjects.
Is this an ad?
Do you not want to go on a Jhourney?
It sure looks like an ad. Even the premise of a "SF meditation startup" sounds pretty bizarre. I wonder what the overlap with the "orgy houses" is?
I suspect people are seeing the title and assuming it's someone talking about meditating and becoming a better person. No, it's a hype piece for a specific SF meditation retreat thing.
If Buddhist practice is really difficult, and makes you perceive every single sensation as profoundly unsatisfactory in some hard-to-define way, and can plunge you into a neverending depression which you might get out of if you meditate hard enough, and then gives you a sort of permanent annoying low-grade bipolar disorder even if you succeed, then we're going to need something better than pithy quotes."
https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/09/18/book-review-mastering-...
That seems like a really good definition
I hadn’t read that before thanks
Edit: I just ordered the book in question! It looks very close to how I’d describe my journey
Started meditating in high school, achieved a temporary awakening where it felt like I was on mushrooms, before I tried mushrooms. Without any visuals of course. You could spit in my face I wouldn't care, I was that happy and content.
Next day.. regular old me. The contrast was so stark it plunged me into a depression because I couldn't achieve that high again.
My advice, don't get into this without a teacher who you trust and is far along that path.
Now I'm back to being Orthodox Christian so wouldn't recommend following that path at all but if you are really interested in Buddhism, at least do it with a good teacher.
Also recommend reading https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/11/28/book-review-the-mind-i...
> * Ironically, Jhourney more or less recommends doing this in various parts of the handbook, but I was too into following rules to follow the part of the rules where they told me to stop following the rules.
LOL
This retreat sounds awesome and I really wish I could afford one!
Edit: Oh, they disallow BorderlinePD and CPTSD, both of which I have:
> Diagnosed or symptoms of borderline personality disorder or complex-PTSD in the last 3 years
I was really excited (and have no hope that anything else comparable will ever happen), but I guess it's not for me.
IIRC, intense meditation can really change one’s experience of those conditions, sometimes for the better, but sometimes making symptoms markedly worse.
I did a 10 day Vipassana retreat a long time ago. Back then it was run by donations and the suggested amount was a couple hundred dollars. They're not out to make money.
Judging by their website, Jhourney isn’t targeting dharma bums. Now that ”mindfulness” is thoroughly mainstreamed, I guess Jhanas is the new thing?